Four Pack Sampler Gift Set

Four-Pack Sampler Gift Set

Can't decide where to start? This is the answer. Our four most popular flavors — two extraordinary extra virgin olive oils and two aged balsamics — brought together in one beautifully presented windowed gift box that is as satisfying to give as it is to receive. The perfect middle ground between our introductory 2-pack and our expansive 6-pack, this set delivers genuine variety, perfect balance, and an immediate sense of just how extraordinary premium olive oil and balsamic can be.

These aren't four random flavors. They are our four best sellers — the bottles that earn permanent spots on more counters than anything else we carry. The ones customers come back for again and again. The ones we recommend first to anyone walking through our door for the very first time.

What's inside:

Tuscan Herb Organic EVOO — Our single most beloved oil, infused with a classic Italian blend of basil, oregano, thyme, and garlic. Warm, savory, and deeply aromatic. The oil that makes everything it touches taste more intentional and more delicious.

Blood Orange Fused EVOO — Made by pressing fresh blood oranges together with the olives at harvest for a bold, vibrant citrus flavor that is completely inseparable from the oil itself. Bright, fruity, and impossible to put down once you've tasted it.

18-Year Aged Traditional Balsamic — Sweet and beautifully complex with notes of ripe fig and raisin, slightly thickened by nearly two decades of patient aging in Modena oak barrels. The balsamic that permanently changes your expectations of what balsamic should taste like.

Cranberry Pear White Balsamic — Real D'Anjou pears bring a gentle honeyed sweetness and delicate floral quality that pairs seamlessly with a bright, very slightly tart cranberry note. Light, versatile, and endlessly surprising across both sweet and savory applications.

Four ways to start tasting:

• Bread dipping — pour the Tuscan Herb EVOO and 18-Year Balsamic side by side in a shallow dish and tear into a crusty baguette. That first dip is the moment everything changes.
• Whisk the Blood Orange EVOO with the Cranberry Pear Balsamic for a stunning vinaigrette over arugula with shaved parmesan
• Drizzle the Blood Orange EVOO over vanilla ice cream and finish with a splash of the Traditional Balsamic
• Toss warm pasta with Tuscan Herb EVOO, a finish of 18-Year Balsamic, and freshly cracked Tellicherry Pepper

Four flavors. Perfect balance. No gift box upcharge — priced as four individual 60ml bottles because the gift itself is enough.

Presented in a beautiful windowed gift box. Ready to give exactly as it arrives — no wrapping required.